My results with rogaine over 3 months (with pics)

[Marshmalo]

those pictures are irrelevant.

Keep the hair buzzed to the same length in each picture. your hair looks better because it is longer.

This.

I don't expect the OP to buzz his hair simply to prove his point but its impossible to make a comparison unless we're seeing the hair in exactly the same situation. In the third pic the hair is longer and has been brushed forward, creating an illusion of thicker hair, I know this because I do it to my own hair to covering up how thin it is.

[Ramazan]

Out of curiosity, what kind of Rogaine are you using? Foam or liquid? 2% or 5%?

Liquid 5 %

[Ramazan]

If this is minox only it makes me really reconsider using it.

It ONLY minox! I don't plan on usin propecia atm.

[Manu84]

This.

I don't expect the OP to buzz his hair simply to prove his point but its impossible to make a comparison unless we're seeing the hair in exactly the same situation. In the third pic the hair is longer and has been brushed forward, creating an illusion of thicker hair, I know this because I do it to my own hair to covering up how thin it is.

What you don't take into account is that in some cases (dunno about OP) that growth you mention just doesn't happen unless you use Minox.