Is the donor region really that limited?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • sausage
    Senior Member
    • Jan 2012
    • 1063

    Is the donor region really that limited?

    I have asked this in my own thread about being conservative when your limited with what you can achieve....

    I think it is important and could be the way for me to go if a surgeon was willing to help me achieve this result.


    Surgeons obviously don't want to extract too many grafts as they don't want the donor area looking too thin. There are always different limitations for different people......

    Are there surgeons or would surgeons consider going beyond their usual recommended limits by 1000, 2000, maybe 3000 grafts if the donor area was filled in with SMP tattooing?

    It would solve the problem for me of not having enough donor hair and I believe that SMP would work well in this situation.

    I understand the back and sides of the head would need to be kept short. A hair style like this could be the end result. Please note that I am only emphasising the hair style I wouldn't expect such a vibrant, full wonderful head of hair although it would be nice:

  • baldymcgee
    Senior Member
    • Mar 2013
    • 118

    #2
    Why not go all the way and swap the entire bald scalp region with hair-bearing regions on the sides/back of your head?

    Then you could get a few thousand FUE *from* the top of your head *to* your sides/back ... adding SMP as needed

    We could be onto something here!

    /s

    Comment

    • TO YOUNG TO RETIRE
      Senior Member
      • Mar 2013
      • 638

      #3
      yes and with the scarless tool and technik dr wesley is going to reveal you could harvest all without scarring

      Comment

      • 35YrsAfter
        Doctor Representative
        • Aug 2012
        • 1418

        #4
        Originally posted by baldymcgee
        Why not go all the way and swap the entire bald scalp region with hair-bearing regions on the sides/back of your head?

        Then you could get a few thousand FUE *from* the top of your head *to* your sides/back ... adding SMP as needed

        We could be onto something here!

        /s
        The hair lift has been tried and the results were in most cases gruesome. See the photos and make up your own mind. The result was scarring and an assortment of unnatural hair directions.

        35YrsAfter also posts as CITNews and works at Dr. Cole's office
        Cole Hair Transplant
        1045 Powers Place
        Alpharetta, Georgia 30009
        Phone 678-566-1011
        Please feel free to call or email me with any questions.
        Attached Files
        Last edited by 35YrsAfter; 02-22-2015, 01:08 PM.

        Comment

        • youngin
          Senior Member
          • Nov 2010
          • 338

          #5
          Originally posted by 35YrsAfter
          The hair lift has been tried and the results were in most cases gruesome. See the photos and make up your own mind. The result was scarring and an assortment of unnatural hair directions.
          WOW lol. I really think they were talking about using FUE to accomplish this though. I have never even heard of the "brandy lift". That is nasty.

          Comment

          • sausage
            Senior Member
            • Jan 2012
            • 1063

            #6
            Originally posted by 35YrsAfter
            The hair lift has been tried and the results were in most cases gruesome. See the photos and make up your own mind. The result was scarring and an assortment of unnatural hair directions.
            ummm. Whatever happend to him is 100% nothing like what we are talking about. WTF happend to that guy!

            Looks like his head was cut up and replaced like a Jigsaw.


            My concept was to use FUE not FUT. Using FUT would be absolutely ridiculous for something like this.

            I would not advise that ALL hair be removed from back and sides.....that is going too far and I am pretty sure would look awful. Maybe taking 50% max so that you still have a decent coverage of texture and then if necessary fill in any sparseness with SMP.

            Comment

            • topcat
              Senior Member
              • May 2009
              • 849

              #7
              Yes The Brandy Lift. It's amazing what youthful desperation can do when those guiding you don't have your best interest at heart. Some of us could have easily died.

              Repair patients are passionate for a reason.

              Comment

              • 35YrsAfter
                Doctor Representative
                • Aug 2012
                • 1418

                #8
                Originally posted by sausage
                ummm. Whatever happend to him is 100% nothing like what we are talking about. WTF happend to that guy!

                Looks like his head was cut up and replaced like a Jigsaw.


                My concept was to use FUE not FUT. Using FUT would be absolutely ridiculous for something like this.

                I would not advise that ALL hair be removed from back and sides.....that is going too far and I am pretty sure would look awful. Maybe taking 50% max so that you still have a decent coverage of texture and then if necessary fill in any sparseness with SMP.
                Many things sound good in theory but just don't turn out as planned in reality. hair/scalp swapping sounds easy enough, but created some very unhappy patients with good reason. Devastated is actually a more appropriate description of how some patients felt. Several years ago, I met a patient who had a Brandy hair lift repaired. The lift caused the hairline above his ears to rise about an inch and a half. This is known as "whitewalls". If that weren't enough, this man had grafts placed in his frontal area by another doctor that were planted too deep resulting in pitting. Dr. Cole repaired this man but it was a long road and took many surgeries.

                It's always best not to be the first and wait to see results in person when there is buzz regarding a "revolutionary" procedure involving a lot of cutting.

                35YrsAfter also posts as CITNews and works at Dr. Cole's office
                Cole Hair Transplant
                1045 Powers Place
                Alpharetta, Georgia 30009
                Phone 678-566-1011
                Please feel free to call or email me with any questions.
                Last edited by 35YrsAfter; 02-22-2015, 01:08 PM.

                Comment

                • topcat
                  Senior Member
                  • May 2009
                  • 849

                  #9
                  Very good point sometimes it all looks good in theory and one should only move forward with those procedures that are time tested. Experimental and new procedures should certainly not be performed on very young men who are often desperate either from hair loss or in my situation to fix the damage that was already done.

                  All it would have taken was one voice of reason to tell the patient listen you do not want to do this Brandy Lift and here is why. I certainly would not consider that bashing the procedure but simply letting the patient know that it’s not as simple as the doctor makes it seem. I would consider this a really good advice for the benefit of the patient and certainly not something negative. I believe the negativity arises when others would try to dismiss another point of view as if it didn’t mean anything.

                  Personally in my own situation I harbor no ill feelings towards Brandy. What really bothers me about what he did was sending in his brother-in-law to seal the deal as he had the procedure performed on himself. I think it’s wrong as at a young age it’s very easy to convince someone as they say like taking candy away from a baby. It probably went something like this “ go in there and tell the kid how great it is and everything will be alright”…………lol………yes I can laugh about it. But I can’t ever imagine doing that to someone.
                  Donor supply in limited you have to have a sensible plan before you do anything and the numbers have to work on paper. If you don’t have an actual sheet of paper using both basic math and geometry you don’t have a plan.

                  Comment

                  • topcat
                    Senior Member
                    • May 2009
                    • 849

                    #10
                    Something that should be pointed out about Brandy is you do have to admit the scars often times were some of the best I have seen. I shaved my sides down and the scar doesn’t bother me much as it is very thin. Not much tension on this one but maybe strip clinics should consider lifting more skin off away from the scalp before they suture it up. Maybe some do this already but the few surgeries I have viewed do not show them doing this.

                    Comment

                    • sausage
                      Senior Member
                      • Jan 2012
                      • 1063

                      #11
                      I see what has been said about seeing someone else have something done first but......

                      Can I just put it straight that the idea I started this thread with is completely different to the stuff u guys are talking about where people have been butchered.....

                      My idea was simply to take a few thousand more grafts from the donor area, thinning it out more than a surgeon usually would and filling in the gaps in the donor region with SMP tattoo. A lot less invasive and a lot more subtle than pulling someone's scalp apart.

                      I do think it is crazy the some people have gone for such crude surgeries in the past.....Hairloss depresses me a lot but I am not sure I could bring myself to get FUT in this day and age. It is such a god damn awful thing to even think about.

                      Comment

                      • Dan26
                        Senior Member
                        • Jul 2012
                        • 1270

                        #12
                        Originally posted by sausage
                        I see what has been said about seeing someone else have something done first but......

                        Can I just put it straight that the idea I started this thread with is completely different to the stuff u guys are talking about where people have been butchered.....

                        My idea was simply to take a few thousand more grafts from the donor area, thinning it out more than a surgeon usually would and filling in the gaps in the donor region with SMP tattoo. A lot less invasive and a lot more subtle than pulling someone's scalp apart.

                        I do think it is crazy the some people have gone for such crude surgeries in the past.....Hairloss depresses me a lot but I am not sure I could bring myself to get FUT in this day and age. It is such a god damn awful thing to even think about.
                        Ya i dont see what is wrong with your idea, especially if...
                        1) You have good donor area
                        2) Use FUE or better yet the scarless technique when it comes out
                        3) You keep your hair on the sides and back short

                        Remember that by the time most people notice they are losing their hair, they have already lost a lot of density. 50% reduction of density in the donor area, as long as its evenly distributed, would probably look ok.

                        Comment

                        • topcat
                          Senior Member
                          • May 2009
                          • 849

                          #13
                          The point of that last photo is all my scalp fue was harvested from that side area and I now have is shaved down which looks very good. I don't need SMP and I think harvesting more fue than normal can be a very good idea especially with this type of cut.

                          Of course you need to have a small session and than shave down the area after a year and make sure you do not have visible scarring. In my case I have seen none and could probably harvest every available hair in that area and still look normal.

                          If I didn't have the strip scarring that is exactly what I would do with the back. High and tight with more hair up on top. In my opinion it looks very good.

                          Comment

                          • baldymcgee
                            Senior Member
                            • Mar 2013
                            • 118

                            #14
                            Originally posted by topcat
                            Something that should be pointed out about Brandy is you do have to admit the scars often times were some of the best I have seen. I shaved my sides down and the scar doesn’t bother me much as it is very thin. Not much tension on this one but maybe strip clinics should consider lifting more skin off away from the scalp before they suture it up. Maybe some do this already but the few surgeries I have viewed do not show them doing this.

                            Can you explain the procedure you had done???

                            Comment

                            • FearTheLoss
                              Senior Member
                              • Dec 2012
                              • 1581

                              #15
                              Originally posted by topcat
                              The point of that last photo is all my scalp fue was harvested from that side area and I now have is shaved down which looks very good. I don't need SMP and I think harvesting more fue than normal can be a very good idea especially with this type of cut.

                              Of course you need to have a small session and than shave down the area after a year and make sure you do not have visible scarring. In my case I have seen none and could probably harvest every available hair in that area and still look normal.

                              If I didn't have the strip scarring that is exactly what I would do with the back. High and tight with more hair up on top. In my opinion it looks very good.

                              So you think what sausage is saying would actually work? With scarless hair transplant, get a "macklemore" style haircut..

                              if you don't know who macklemore is google image him, he's a white rapper from seattle that kind of started this new modern hairstyle..

                              Comment

                              Working...