Rogaine Foam vs. Liquid

[Californication]

Hi, I was on the liquid for 4 months and then switched to the foam and have been on that for 5 months because the liquid gave me an insane amount of flaking.

Was wondering which one you guys think works better? Or the same? This is a pretty common question, I've searched it on the web extensively, but haven't really been able to find a consensus.

[PatientlyWaiting]

The liquid is better. I use both though.

[john2399]

Foam all day. Liquid too messy.

[PatientlyWaiting]

Foam all day. Liquid too messy.

Yes, that's true that the liquid is messy.

But he asked which one works better. Liquid works better, it has PPG, which helps penetrate the skin better.

[marikeo]

Yes, that's true that the liquid is messy.

But he asked which one works better. Liquid works better, it has PPG, which helps penetrate the skin better.

Switching to Foam from Liquid 10 months ago caused major shedding for me. Only now it is just stabilizing. However, the cosmetic benefit of the Foam makes it the only "day" option for me. Liquid at night as always.